Top 2000s Indie Rock Vinyl Records Worth Money
Looking to sell your old indie rock vinyl? Many albums from the 2000s have become surprisingly valuable—especially first pressings, limited runs, and imports.
That’s because vinyl production was at an all-time low during this era, as CDs and MP3s dominated the music industry. As a result, many great 2000s indie albums were pressed in small quantities, making them highly collectible today.
Whether you're downsizing your collection or just curious what's worth keeping, this list highlights some of the most sought-after 2000s indie rock LPs among collectors.
🎵 10 Valuable 2000s Indie Rock Vinyl Albums
1. Radiohead – In Rainbows (2007, XL Recordings)
Originally released digitally as a “pay what you want” experiment, early physical vinyl versions—especially the deluxe box set—are highly prized by collectors.
2. Arcade Fire – Funeral (2004, Merge)
A modern classic. First U.S. pressings are more valuable than later reissues, particularly sealed copies or those with lyric inserts.
3. Sufjan Stevens – Illinois (2005, Asthmatic Kitty)
Early pressings featuring Superman on the artwork were recalled, making those versions rare and collectible.
4. The Shins – Chutes Too Narrow (2003, Sub Pop)
Beloved indie pop album. Colored vinyl editions and first-run Sub Pop pressings are especially in demand.
5. Bon Iver – For Emma, Forever Ago (2007, Jagjaguwar)
Limited initial runs from the Eau Claire indie scene are now collector items, especially those pre-dating the Jagjaguwar release.
6. TV on the Radio – Return to Cookie Mountain (2006, Interscope)
Low initial vinyl runs + critical acclaim = steady value rise. UK pressings and special editions are most sought after.
7. Modest Mouse – The Moon & Antarctica (2000, Epic)
The band’s major label debut had a modest vinyl run. First pressings in good condition fetch top dollar.
8. Interpol – Turn on the Bright Lights (2002, Matador)
First pressings with printed inner sleeves and inserts remain highly collectible and hard to find.
9. Death Cab for Cutie – Transatlanticism (2003, Barsuk)
Vinyl copies were limited early on. Original pressings with the gatefold cover and lyric sheet are desirable.
10. The Postal Service – Give Up (2003, Sub Pop)
Sub Pop’s second best-selling album ever. First pressings—especially with hype stickers or colored vinyl—have held their value.
💬 Thinking About Selling Your Indie Rock Vinyl?
If you own any of these titles—or a whole collection of 2000s indie rock—we’re always buying.
✅ We buy individual records or full collections
✅ Fast quotes, fair prices, and local service
✅ We come to you for large collections
We Buy Records Chicago
📞 Call us at (312) 500-4546 or
💬 Text (630) 544-9733 to get started.
❓ FAQ: Selling 2000s Indie Rock Vinyl
Is 2000s indie rock vinyl actually worth anything?
Yes! Vinyl production was low in the early 2000s, so many indie albums were released in small quantities. First pressings and imports are especially collectible.
How can I tell if my indie vinyl is valuable?
Start by checking the label, pressing info (often in the runout groove), and whether it's a first pressing. You can also text us photos for a quick review.
Where can I sell indie vinyl records near me?
We offer house calls in Illinois and parts of Indiana and Michigan for larger collections, we also buy at our shop in Westchester, IL. Message us to make an appointment!